It’s been another horrible week for antivaxxers.
A study, Autism Occurrence by MMR Vaccine Status Among US Children With Older Siblings With and Without Autism, was published. The researchers used data in the Optum Research Database. This database contains anonymised data of claims from Medicare and private health insurers. Their rationale was:
Families with a child affected by ASD may be particularly concerned about reports linking MMR and ASD, despite the lack of evidence. Surveys of parents who have children with ASD suggest that many believe the MMR vaccine was a contributing cause. This belief, combined with knowing that younger siblings of children with ASD are already at higher genetic risk for ASD compared with the general population, might prompt these parents to avoid vaccinating their younger children…
Thus, we set out to report on ASD occurrence by MMR vaccine status in a large sample of US children having older siblings with ASD and to compare findings with those among children who have older siblings without ASD.
MMR vaccine receipt was not associated with an increased risk of ASD at any age.
In California, Senate Bill 277, intended to remove philosophical exemptions from vaccination, passed out of committee and will now go before the State Senate to be voted on. More here. It looks like with that Measles outbreak at Disneyland, people have now started realising that non-vaccinators are eroding herd immunity and wanting action taken.
And Vermont is doing the same.
The Vermont Senate has voted to end the philosophical exemption some parents use to decline to have their children vaccinated. The Legislation would require the full range of required vaccinations as a pre-condition to enrolling in school.
Full article here.
It’s official. Australia has decided that people who don’t vaccinate will not be eligible to claim certain rebates.
The religious exemption has also been tightened. From now on, only Christian Scientists will be eligible for the religious exemption.
Yesterday, I did not “light it up blue” for autism awareness. Instead, I intend to “Tone it down Taupe” and “Walk in Red”.
This may come as a surprise to some, but I had my reasons. The problem is, the slogan has been captured by Autism Speaks, an organisation that, despite its name, does not speak for autistics. Instead, it ignores, undermines and degrades us with its actions.
The biggest problem with Autism Speaks is its consistent use of the “Autism is a tragedy” narrative, to the point that John Elder Robison resigned from the Autism Speaks Board. Autism Speaks refuses to listen to those autistics who say that we have #ALifeWorthLiving
A second problem is that only a fraction of the money donated to Autism Speaks is used to help autistics and their families.
A third problem is that Autism Speaks initially bought into the MMR Autism causation hypothesis, and still refuses to distance itself from its earlier position. At the start of 2009, Alison Tepper Singer was the Vice President for PR and Strategy at Autism Speaks when the first three cases in the Omnibus Autism proceedings were judged. When the verdicts went against the families, Singer took a much closer look at the evidence and realised just how poor it was. But when she tried to get Autism Speaks to change its approach, she failed. She then left Autism Speaks and set up the Autism Science Foundation.
Recently Rob Ring, Autism Speaks’ Chief Science Officer, put out a statement unequivocally denying the vaccine autism link. But then Bob Wright, cofounder of Autism Speaks, commented.
Over the last two decades extensive research has asked whether there is any link between childhood vaccines and autism. Scientific research has not directly connected autism to vaccines. Vaccines are very important. Parents must make the decision whether to vaccinate their children. Efforts must be continually made to educate parents about vaccine safety. If parents decide not to vaccinate they must be aware of the consequences in their community and their local schools.
The comment is ambiguous and equivocal. Wright should have confirmed that autism and vaccines aren’t linked. Instead, he suggests there may still be something to it.
With Autism Speaks, the bad it does far outweighs the good.
Another baby has fallen victim to whooping cough.
Riley Hughes wasn’t even five weeks old. He wasn’t the only one. According to the article linked above.
There have been three whooping cough deaths in babies in NSW since 2009, including a six month old unvaccinated twin who died last September in regional NSW.
Revoltingly, the anti-vaxxers have begun their attack, just as they did when David and Toni McCaffrey lost their baby daughter Dana. The McCaffreys have sent the Hugheses condolences.
In Germany, an 18 month old unvaccinated child died from measles. The result has been calls for mandatory vaccination. I am very surprised that mandatory vaccination doesn’t already exist in Germany.
Please vaccinate and get your boosters.
AT LAST, SIR TERRY, WE MUST WALK TOGETHER.
Terry took Death’s arm and followed him through the doors and on to the black desert under the endless night.
With those three tweets, the death of fantasy author and Discworld creator Sir Terry Pratchett was announced to the world. He had a form of Alzheimer’s disease, and that is what took him. Oddly enough, I went to see “Still Alice” on Sunday. Julianne Moore won a Best Actress Oscar for her depiction of a linguistics professor suffering from early-onset Alzheimer’s. Joyreactor has a tribute to Sir Terry. It doesn’t link to the source, unfortunately.
I saw an article about a link between autism and intelligence. The investigators say more research needs to be done, but I thought it was interesting.
Next up, something for pro vaxxers to smirk about.
A German antivaccinationist named Stefan Lanka offered 100,000 Euros to anyone who could irrefutably demonstrate the existence of the measles virus. A physician named David Barden accepted the challenge and sent Lanka peer reviewed documentation. Lanka refused to accept the proof and pay out the prize, so Barden sued him in court.
Lanka has announced he will appeal, but I doubt he will be successful as the judge declared the terms of the challenge were met.
And unfortunately, I’m going to have to end this on a major downer.
An autistic teenager named Otto Smith was murdered by his mother’s live-in boyfriend. The boyfriend, Matthew Lee Christenson, has a history of assault.
Posted in Anti-antivaccination, Autism Awareness, Background Data, Fun Stuff, Life, Segue
Tagged Abuse of autistics, Alzheimer's Syndrome, Autism Research, Court Cases, Crimes against autistics, Films I've seen, Measles, Murder, Still Alice, Terry Pratchett
Some two and a half years ago, one of the most egregious verdicts in history was returned by a lower court in Rimini, Italy.
The court ruled that the MMR vaccine caused autism.
I wrote about it then. To reach this execrable verdict, the court relied heavily on Andrew Wakefield’s fraudulent and retracted “case study”. Given that it had been retracted for over two years already at that point, the decision was a travesty.
And now, justice has prevailed.
On the 13th February, a higher court overturned the verdict, ruling that it was completely wrong to rely on Wakefield’s “research”.
I used Chrome’s “translate” feature as I don’t know Italian. The first paragraph reads:
There is no link between the trivalent vaccine and autism. There is no evidence to establish that the former causes the syndrome, there is only a temporal connection. In the sense that the injection that prevents measles, mumps and rubella is made before the diagnosis of autistic disorder, which usually arrives between 3 and 6 years. That’s it. The Court of Appeal of Bologna has overturned a controversial 2102 ruling of the Labour Court of Rimini, who had recognized the compensation to a couple of Romagna whose child had been vaccinated by local health authorities in 2002 and subsequently had a diagnosis of autism.
The verdict led to a fall in vaccination rates. Hopefully, this too will be corrected.
A few things before the main event.
Pro-vaxxers have two new celebrity allies. Kristen Bell and her husband Dax Shepard are not allowing their friends near their children unless they’ve been vaccinated.
Cracked has an article on why anti-vaccine lies work so well.
And now the story that has me shaking with rage. THIS.
That article is straight up apologetics for murder. Matt has a much more accurate view.
For more information, please go to Respectful Insolence and search on “Alex Spourdalakis”.
This is just downright evil. It’s the same “autism is a tragedy” lie that devalues my life and the life of every single other autistic. Spourdalakis’s caregivers are not good people. They were offered help and they refused. Then they violently murdered Alex.
This just makes me want to scream “STOP DEVALUING US!!!” Because that is precisely what it’s doing.